3 replaced http://physics.stackexchange.com/ with https://physics.stackexchange.com/
source | link

Basic circuit problemBasic circuit problem

The question poses a set piece, shows the OP's working, and asks us to explain what is wrong with their working.

With a bit of work, it can be rephrased into something that's less dependent on the set piece and helping the OP understand how that circuit behaves as he's being told it behaves. It has an accepted answer which does a good job at addressing the conceptual difficulty at the heart of the question. However, even if fixed, it probably wouldn't be a great question.

Vote up if you think this should be on topic under the new policy, or vote down if you think it should be off topic under the new policy.

Basic circuit problem

The question poses a set piece, shows the OP's working, and asks us to explain what is wrong with their working.

With a bit of work, it can be rephrased into something that's less dependent on the set piece and helping the OP understand how that circuit behaves as he's being told it behaves. It has an accepted answer which does a good job at addressing the conceptual difficulty at the heart of the question. However, even if fixed, it probably wouldn't be a great question.

Vote up if you think this should be on topic under the new policy, or vote down if you think it should be off topic under the new policy.

Basic circuit problem

The question poses a set piece, shows the OP's working, and asks us to explain what is wrong with their working.

With a bit of work, it can be rephrased into something that's less dependent on the set piece and helping the OP understand how that circuit behaves as he's being told it behaves. It has an accepted answer which does a good job at addressing the conceptual difficulty at the heart of the question. However, even if fixed, it probably wouldn't be a great question.

Vote up if you think this should be on topic under the new policy, or vote down if you think it should be off topic under the new policy.

2 added 118 characters in body
source | link

Basic circuit problem

The question poses a set piece, shows the OP's working, and asks us to explain what is wrong with their working.

With a bit of work, it can be rephrased into something that's less dependent on the set piece and helping the OP understand how that circuit behaves as he's being told it behaves. It has an accepted answer which does a good job at addressing the conceptual difficulty at the heart of the question. However, even if fixed, it probably wouldn't be a great question.

Vote up if you think this should be on topic under the new policy, or vote down if you think it should be off topic under the new policy.

Basic circuit problem

The question poses a set piece, shows the OP's working, and asks us to explain what is wrong with their working.

With a bit of work, it can be rephrased into something that's less dependent on the set piece and helping the OP understand how that circuit behaves as he's being told it behaves. However, even if fixed, it probably wouldn't be a great question.

Vote up if you think this should be on topic under the new policy, or vote down if you think it should be off topic under the new policy.

Basic circuit problem

The question poses a set piece, shows the OP's working, and asks us to explain what is wrong with their working.

With a bit of work, it can be rephrased into something that's less dependent on the set piece and helping the OP understand how that circuit behaves as he's being told it behaves. It has an accepted answer which does a good job at addressing the conceptual difficulty at the heart of the question. However, even if fixed, it probably wouldn't be a great question.

Vote up if you think this should be on topic under the new policy, or vote down if you think it should be off topic under the new policy.

1
source | link

Basic circuit problem

The question poses a set piece, shows the OP's working, and asks us to explain what is wrong with their working.

With a bit of work, it can be rephrased into something that's less dependent on the set piece and helping the OP understand how that circuit behaves as he's being told it behaves. However, even if fixed, it probably wouldn't be a great question.

Vote up if you think this should be on topic under the new policy, or vote down if you think it should be off topic under the new policy.