# Is this an homework or check-my-work type question?

I recently asked this question on Physics Stack Exchange. I wanted to know if this is an homework or check my work type question?

• It might be closed under Needs details or clarity. – SarGe Aug 18 at 11:40
• The question has been reopened, but I still suggest making the changes I outline in my answer here. – BioPhysicist Aug 18 at 17:55

I think this line

How can we explain this phenomenon using ray diagrams?

is the issue. At first glance it makes it look like you are just asking for someone to make a ray diagram for you rather than asking about physics concepts here.

An easy fix could be something like

From ray diagrams it can easily be concluded that using a real object, we cannot get a real image from a plane mirror. But, if we shine a torch on the mirror we see a real image on the wall. Why does a real image form despite ray diagrams showing they do not form?

This puts the focus on understanding what constitutes a real image, and how they relate to ray diagrams.

It might also help to explain why you think it is a real image (and not just light reflecting off a surface), and maybe even your ray diagrams showing how real images do not form.

• Thank you!! That very useful! I will keep that in mind when asking my next question. Also thank you for reopening the question! – Arnav Mahajan Aug 19 at 3:29