Here are two questions that do not make sense, while reading them:
My observation is that second question doesn't get better if you read the answers. I didn't learn anything new from the answers. It just looked to me like a philosophical exercise in renaming things for the sake of renaming things.
On the other hand the first question actually did got better when I read the answer. I've learnt something new. I've got better understanding of the particle physics experiment.
What bugs me is the moderator response to both situations. It was the first question that was blocked -- not the second one. I think that something is wrong with that. And I think that it has something to do with the standard complaint about "not enough experts" that you guys have here.